Why rankings drop after a move
Search engines rank addresses, not stores. Every product page, collection and blog post that brings you visitors today is ranked under its current address. Move to Shopify and almost all of those addresses change.
If nothing tells Google where each page went, it finds a “Page not found” where your best page used to be. Over the following weeks, those pages drop out of the results, along with the links other sites gave them. That’s where lost rankings after a migration come from, far more often than from the platform itself.
The fix is a redirect map: a list that pairs every old address with its new one, turned into permanent (301) redirects. Google’s own site move guide recommends exactly that. Build it before launch day and the move becomes a change of address, not a fresh start.
Step 1: list every address you have
Before you change anything, collect every address your current store has, from more than one source. Each one finds pages the others miss:
- Your current sitemap. Usually at
/sitemap.xml. It lists the pages your platform knows about. - A crawl of your site. A crawler such as Screaming Frog follows every link and finds pages that never made it into the sitemap.
- Google Search Console. The Performance report shows which pages get impressions and clicks. These are the pages you can’t afford to lose.
- Your analytics. Landing pages from the last 12 months, including ones only reached from emails or ads.
- Links from other sites. Search Console’s Links report shows which of your pages other sites link to.
Put them all in one spreadsheet, remove duplicates, and add a column with each page’s clicks or visits. That tells you which rows to check most carefully later.
Step 2: build the redirect map
Add a second column: the new Shopify address for each old one. Shopify’s addresses follow a fixed pattern, and you can’t rename these folders:
- Products:
/products/merino-crew-jumper - Collections:
/collections/knitwear - Pages:
/pages/about-us - Blog posts:
/blogs/news/how-to-wash-woolon the default blog
The part after the folder, the handle, is yours to choose. Keep it the same as your old slug where you can. A product at /shop/merino-crew-jumper.html becomes /products/merino-crew-jumper, and the map almost writes itself.
Then work through the rules:
- One old address, one new address. Send each page to its closest match: a product to the same product, a category to the matching collection.
- No chains. If an old page already redirected somewhere, point it straight at the final Shopify address, not through a second hop.
- Don’t send everything to the home page. Visitors land somewhere they didn’t ask for, and search engines tend to treat that like a missing page.
- Remember the odd ones. Old campaign landing pages, filtered category URLs that rank, PDF guides and image addresses linked from other sites.
- Use patterns for big catalogs. If thousands of addresses follow the same pattern, a rule for the pattern saves writing every row by hand.
Search engines rank addresses, not stores. Tell them where every page went.
Step 3: carry over what ranks
A redirect sends visitors to the new page. What they find there decides whether the ranking holds. For your top pages, carry over:
- Page titles and meta descriptions. In Shopify they’re in each product’s and collection’s search engine listing. Copy them over rather than letting Shopify use the product name.
- The text. Product descriptions, collection intros and blog posts. A page that lost half its words is a different page to a search engine.
- Image alt text, especially if you get traffic from image search.
- Your internal links. Links inside descriptions and blog posts still point at old addresses. They’ll redirect, but fix them so every click lands directly.
- Reviews. If product reviews show on your pages today, import them into your new review app before launch.
Step 4: launch day
- Import the redirects. In Shopify admin, go to Content > Menus > URL redirects and import your map as a CSV with a “Redirect from” and a “Redirect to” column. Shopify allows up to 100,000 URL redirects, or 20,000,000 on Shopify Plus.
- Point your domain at Shopify. Keeping the same domain is the simplest move for search: only the paths change.
- Test the top rows. Open your most visited old addresses in a private window. Each should land on the right page in one hop.
- Submit your new sitemap. Shopify creates it at
/sitemap.xml. Submit it in Google Search Console and Bing Webmaster Tools. - Changing domain too? Then keep the old domain registered, redirect it, and use Search Console’s Change of Address tool. Google says you only need that tool when the domain or subdomain changes.
Step 5: the weeks after
Google says to expect rankings to move up and down for a while during a site move. That’s normal. What you’re watching for is anything that doesn’t come back:
- Check Search Console every week. The Pages report lists addresses Google found missing (“Not found (404)”). Each one is a row your map missed.
- Compare your top pages. Clicks and positions for the pages from your spreadsheet, before and after. A page that keeps falling usually lost content or a title, not its redirect.
- Keep the redirects. Google recommends keeping them as long as possible, and generally at least a year. Old emails, bookmarks and links on other sites will use those addresses for years, so there’s little reason ever to remove them.
Search Console only shows what search engines tried to crawl, usually with a delay. Customers hit broken addresses too, from old emails and bookmarks, and those never show up there. Watching 404s as they happen is what catches the rest.
Questions
Will I lose my Google rankings if I move to Shopify?
You can expect some movement for a few weeks; Google says rankings may fluctuate temporarily during any site move. Lasting losses usually come from missing redirects, lost content or changed titles. With a 301 redirect for every old address and the same content on the new pages, most stores recover.
Can I keep my old URLs on Shopify?
Mostly not. Shopify puts products under /products/, collections under /collections/ and pages under /pages/, and those subdirectory names can’t be changed. You can usually keep the last part of the address (the handle) the same as your old slug, which makes the redirect map simpler.
How do I add redirects in bulk on Shopify?
In Shopify admin, go to Content > Menus > URL redirects and import a CSV file with a “Redirect from” and a “Redirect to” column. Shopify allows up to 100,000 URL redirects, or 20,000,000 on Shopify Plus.
Why isn’t my Shopify redirect working?
A Shopify URL redirect only applies when the old address shows “Page not found”. If a page still exists at that address, the redirect is ignored. Check that nothing on your new store uses the old path.
How long should I keep the redirects?
Google recommends keeping them as long as possible, and generally at least a year. In practice, keep them for good: links in old emails, bookmarks and other sites keep using the old addresses for years.
Do I need Google’s Change of Address tool?
Only if your domain changes, for example from oldstore.com to newstore.com. If you keep the same domain and only the paths change, you don’t need it.
Sources: Google Search Central’s guide to site moves with URL changes, and the Shopify Help Center pages on URL redirects and domain terminology.
